How we estimate over-assessment in Cook County

All inputs are public Cook County Assessor data: parcel records, assessed values, home characteristics and recorded sales. We re-run the analysis whenever the Assessor publishes new values. This page explains each step so you can check our work. (Texas uses a different method; see the Texas methodology.)

Data

We cover single-family and small multi-family homes (classes 202–295). Condos are not yet covered.

The Assessor's implied value

Residential property is assessed at 10% of market value, so assessed value ÷ 10% is the Assessor's estimate of market value.

Test 1: comparable sales (overvaluation)

We look at recent arm's-length sales of similar homes nearby: the same property class, comparable in size and age. Their sale prices, adjusted to the home's size, give the sales-indicated value. This is the "overvaluation" argument the Assessor and the Board of Review accept.

Test 2: uniformity

We compare the home's assessment with similar nearby homes' assessments, adjusted to its size. That gives the uniformity-indicated assessed value: the "lack of uniformity" argument.

Verdict

A home is "likely over-assessed" when it's at least 10% above either test, the estimated tax effect is at least $250 a year, and there are enough comparables to judge. Otherwise it's "fairly assessed", or "not enough data" if there aren't enough comparables. In the free check, a home shows as a strong case only when both tests agree; one test alone shows as mixed. Comparable homes and sales are adjusted to the home's size the way values actually scale in Cook County (a larger home is worth less per square foot), not at a flat rate per square foot.

Tax math

Estimated tax = (assessed value × state equalizer 3.03 − $10,000 homeowner exemption) × composite tax rate. We use the Cook County Clerk's published 2024 composite rate for the home's tax code (about 94% of homes). Where a tax code is newer than the Clerk's report, we use the median rate of nearby homes in the same assessor neighborhood. Rates change a little every year, so the dollar figures are estimates.

What the savings figure means

"Estimated savings" assumes the value is cut all the way to what the evidence supports. Real appeal results are often smaller, because the Assessor and Board of Review frequently grant part of a reduction. Treat it as the upper end.

Limitations

Estimates, not appraisals. Home condition, renovations and details the Assessor doesn't publish aren't reflected. Sales can be scarce in some areas, which is why we also use uniformity. The Assessor and Board of Review decide every appeal on its own evidence.

A worked example

A two-story frame home of 1,800 sq ft is assessed at $36,000, so the Assessor's implied value is $360,000 ($200 per sq ft). Recent arm's-length sales of similar homes nearby point to about $180 per sq ft, which points to $324,000. Similar nearby homes are assessed at about $18.50 per sq ft, which points to an assessed value of $33,300. The home is 11% above the sales test and 8% above the uniformity test. With a typical rate, the tax effect of correcting it to the sales value is several hundred dollars a year, so it's flagged "likely over-assessed".

How accurate is it?

We back-tested the value estimate on 4,972 real Cook County sales: for each, we estimated the home's value from other sales exactly as the check does, then compared it with what it actually sold for.

That's why results show a savings range and plain signals, not a single figure, and why a recent appraisal or purchase price, when you have one, is stronger evidence than our estimate.

What happened to real assessments

We scored 25,000 homes on their 2025 mailed assessments with the check's two tests, then looked at whether the Assessor or the Board of Review lowered them.

How the check would have read itHomesLoweredTypical cut when lowered
Both tests 10%+ over (shown as a strong case)37125%13.8%
One test 10%+ over (shown as mixed)2,78116%about 7–10%
Not flagged21,84813%6.6%

The county doesn't publish who appealed, so "lowered" mixes how often owners appealed with how often they won; compare the rows with each other. Homes where both tests agree were lowered most often and by the most, which is why only those show as a strong case.

We also publish area statistics only where enough homes stand behind them; areas without enough data show none.

Sources

Last updated November 21, 2026. Data: Cook County Assessor open data. How we calculate this.