Flat fee vs contingency fee for a property tax appeal: the break-even
A $49 flat fee costs less than a contingency fee once your first-year tax saving is above $196 at 25%, $163 at 30%, $123 at 40% or $98 at 50%. Below that, the percentage is cheaper; above it, the flat fee wins, and the gap grows every year the firm charges again.
| Contingency fee | A $49 flat fee costs less once your first-year saving is above |
|---|---|
| 25% | $196 |
| 30% | $163 |
| 35% | $140 |
| 40% | $122 |
| 50% | $98 |
Try your own number
Questions to ask before signing a contingency agreement
- What percentage, and of which years' savings?
- Is there a minimum fee, or a fee on value cuts that don't lower your bill?
- Does it renew automatically each year, and how do you cancel?
- Who attends the hearing, and who decides whether to settle?
The free check shows three clear signals for your own home from the public record: how strong the case is, how much is at stake, and what the evidence looks like.
Questions
What does 'first-year savings' mean?
The drop in this year's tax bill. Many firms charge only on that year, even when the lower value carries into later years; some charge on several years. Read the agreement.
Is a percentage fee ever better?
Yes: when the saving is small, when you won't file yourself, or when the case needs a lawyer (tax court, business-owned property in New Jersey).
Sources
- Ownwell fees by state (Money Crashers review)
- O'Connor, Cook County: 30% of the taxes saved for that tax year
- Example Cook County attorney engagement letter: 30% of first-year tax savings
- New Jersey appeal guide: attorneys typically 25–50% of first-year savings; Freeze Act protection
Checked November 2026.
Last updated November 21, 2026. Data: each company's published prices and the public sources linked on this page.
