Hire a protest company or do it yourself? An honest comparison
Updated November 21, 2026 · Applies to the 2027 protest season
Texas has a large industry of property tax consultants who file and argue your protest for a share of the savings. Many homeowners do fine with them. Many others pay a large share of their savings for something they could do in an hour. Here's how to decide.
What companies charge
Most residential protest firms work on contingency: nothing if they don't get a reduction, otherwise a percentage of the first year's tax savings. Published rates run from about 25% to 50%, and some add per-account or minimum fees. Because they refile every year, the fee recurs every year your value is cut.
What the 2026 Harris County data says
| 2026 protests (single-family homes) | Got a reduction | Typical cut if reduced |
|---|---|---|
| Filed by the owner | 81% | 6% |
| Filed by an agent | 88% | 7% |
Agents won somewhat more often and got slightly larger cuts. Owners still won most of the time. Agents also pick their clients, so part of the gap may be case selection.
The math
Say a protest saves $1,000 in tax this year.
- Company at 30%: you keep $700; the company keeps $300. Repeat every year.
- Company at 50%: you keep $500.
- Do it yourself with a $49 evidence kit: you keep $951, and the evidence takes about an hour to put together.
If an agent's higher success rate adds a little to the expected result, the fee still usually costs more than it adds on an ordinary home.
When a company makes sense
- You have several properties or a complex one (a large rental, commercial property).
- You don't want to attend a meeting or hearing at all.
- The case is likely to go to arbitration or court.
When DIY makes sense
- A single-family home with comparable homes in the same neighborhood.
- You can spend an hour on evidence and 15 minutes at an informal meeting.
- You'd rather keep the full savings every year.
We sell a do-it-yourself evidence kit, so we have an interest in this comparison. The figures above are from HCAD's public 2026 hearing data and the firms' published fees.
Frequently asked questions
How much do property tax protest companies charge in Texas?
Most charge about 25% to 50% of the first year's tax savings on contingency, and the fee recurs each year they win a reduction.
Do agents win more often than homeowners?
In Harris County in 2026, agent-filed protests on single-family homes got a reduction 88% of the time versus 81% for owner-filed ones.
Is it hard to protest on my own?
No. Filing online takes about ten minutes, and most reductions come from an online offer or a short informal meeting.
Related guides
- How to file a Harris County protest online with iFile
- Unequal appraisal: the Texas protest argument most homeowners don't use
- The HCAD informal meeting: what to expect
Sources
General information, not legal or tax advice. Rules and procedures can change; check your notice and HCAD for your exact dates.
Last updated November 21, 2026. Data: HCAD public data: 2026 appraisal roll (notice and certified values) and 2026 protest hearing records. How we calculate this.
